What Happened to Janice Hartman?

Janice Elaine Hartman was born on March 2, 1951, and grew up in a close-knit community in Ohio. Known for her bright smile and engaging personality, Janice was beloved by those who knew her. She exhibited a caring nature from a young age, which made her popular among her peers and cherished within her family. Before her untimely disappearance, Janice’s life was filled with the promise of personal and professional growth, reflecting her aspirations and dreams for the future.

In her early twenties, Janice married John David Smith III on June 30, 1970. The couple initially seemed happy, but the marriage quickly deteriorated. Friends and family noted a change in Janice’s demeanor shortly after the marriage, citing increased isolation and signs of distress. Her brother, Gary Hartman, would later recount that Janice had experienced abuse at the hands of her husband, which drastically affected her well-being and ultimately led to her decision to leave Smith.

Marriage and Disappearance

The marriage between Janice Hartman and John David Smith III was fraught with difficulties, primarily due to Smith’s abusive behavior. By 1974, Janice decided she could no longer endure the marriage and returned to Ohio to file for divorce. The court granted her divorce on November 14, 1974. Mere days after her divorce was finalized, on November 17, 1974, Janice told her family she would be going away for a while. This was the last time anyone from her family would hear from her.

Janice’s sudden disappearance following her announcement alarmed her family and friends, who were aware of the abusive nature of her recently ended marriage. When she did not return, and no further communication was forthcoming, her disappearance became a significant concern. Despite their fears and suspicions, it took several years before her family could convince law enforcement to investigate her husband as a potential suspect.

Investigation and Discovery

For years, Janice Hartman’s disappearance remained a mystery. Her family’s attempts to find her were met with frustrating obstacles, partly due to the lack of physical evidence and the initial unwillingness of law enforcement to pursue her case aggressively. This changed dramatically in 1979 when a chilling discovery was made. John Smith’s brother, Michael Smith, observed John building a narrow wooden box, which he later discovered contained a dismembered body believed to be Janice’s. This box, however, was not opened by law enforcement until it was found abandoned in an Indiana field in 1980.

The remains were not immediately identified as belonging to Janice Hartman until two decades later, in 2000. This breakthrough came as a result of renewed investigative efforts and advancements in forensic technology. The identification of her remains finally allowed law enforcement to move forward with charges against John David Smith III, providing the Hartman family with some answers after many years of agonizing uncertainty.

Legal Proceedings and Outcome

Following the identification of Janice Hartman’s remains, her ex-husband, John David Smith III, was arrested and charged with her murder. In 2001, he was convicted of the murder of Janice Hartman and sentenced to 15 years to life in prison. His trial revealed the brutal nature of his crimes and his capacity for deception. Smith’s conviction was a significant, albeit painful, victory for Janice’s family, who had long suspected his involvement in her disappearance and death.

Janice Hartman’s story is a tragic example of the hidden dangers that can exist within troubled relationships. Her case also highlights the importance of perseverance and advocacy by families in seeking justice for their loved ones. While the conviction of John David Smith III provided legal closure, the loss of Janice continues to impact her family and community, reminding them of the need for vigilance and support for those experiencing domestic abuse.

More Dateline: Chameleon

• “Chameleon”: Dateline Reports on Murderer John Smith April 26 2024
• Where is John David Smith III Now? 2024 Update & Background
• What Happened to Fran Gladden-Smith?